As musicians, it is common for us to offer and seek feedback on our musical creations. In this blog post, I will provide 5 important tips to help you become better at delivering constructive criticism, whether it’s for others’ works or your own.
1. Be specific and focused in your feedback. Avoid vague criticisms that do not provide any helpful insights. Instead, choose specific elements to critique, such as the song’s form, harmony, dynamics, and melody. Analyze these aspects to identify areas for improvement and suggest actionable solutions.
2. Be efficient and timely with your feedback. Music evokes emotions, so trust your initial gut reactions and thoughts. Take note of your feedback upon first hearing a track. Later, confirm your observations by giving it a second listen. Avoid overthinking and dwelling too long on your feedback.
3. Maintain objectivity in your criticism. Music is subjective, and we all have personal preferences. If you feel that your feedback stems from a bias, communicate it to the artist so they understand your standpoint. Differentiate between your personal preferences and general industry practices when offering feedback.
4. Avoid overwhelming artists with excessive feedback. Lengthy critiques may not be useful, especially for independent producers. Prioritize the most significant issues you identify in the song, as solving major problems often resolves minor ones. Focus on the areas that will have the greatest impact on the overall quality of the music.
5. Offer constructive suggestions, not just criticism. Merely stating what you dislike about a track without providing solutions is unhelpful. Make concrete recommendations for improvement. For example, instead of saying you dislike a certain element, propose specific changes or adjustments that could enhance the song’s quality.
If you’d like to practice your constructive criticism skills, consider engaging with online communities where musicians share their works-in-progress. Listen to their tracks and leave comments or private messages with your constructive feedback.
Feel free to share any additional methods or techniques you use to provide constructive feedback in the comments section below.
Date: July 6, 2017
English 
Spanish
Leave a Reply